Employ
RecruitPayapa Global vs Deel
Running a global team introduces several HR challenges, from managing employee benefits and payroll across different regions to navigating complex legal requirements in multiple countries. These tasks demand solutions that not only simplify but also ensure compliance and efficiency in global operations.
Enter the Employer of Record (EOR) services—your strategic partner for managing international employees. EOR platforms take on the burden of administrative tasks, legal obligations, and regulatory compliance, allowing companies to operate seamlessly across borders.
In this guide, we’ll compare two of the most prominent EOR providers—Papaya Global and Deel —and evaluate how they can help you overcome global HR hurdles.
What You’ll Discover:
- In-Depth Feature Analysis: A thorough breakdown of the features and usability of both platforms.
- Pricing Comparison: A detailed look at the costs associated with each service to assist with effective budgeting.
- Pros and Cons: Unbiased assessments of the strengths and limitations of Papaya Global and Deel.
By the end of this review, you’ll be equipped with the knowledge to confidently select the EOR provider that will best support your global team and keep your business compliant across borders.
Papaya Global vs Deel Overview
Feature | Papaya Global | Deel | Explanation |
User Reviews | G2: 4.5/5 Trustpilot: 2.4/5 | G2: 4.8/5 Trustpilot: 4.9/5 | Deel’s reviews are excellent. Papaya Global’s are between middling and very good. |
Pricing | $599/ employee per month; $30/contractor per month | $599/employee per month; $49/contractor per month | Both service providers post their basic fees online. Their EOR fees are the same, but Papaya Global is cheaper for contractors. |
User-friendliness | Very good | Very good | Both companies feature easy-to-use platforms. |
Customer Support | 24/7live chat support | 24/7 live chat support | Both Deel and Papaya Global offer 24/7 live chat support through their platforms. |
Integrations | Good | Very good | Deel has an API and integration with over 90 major HR and accounting apps like Ashby, QuickBooks, and Xero. Papaya Global also has an API and can integrate with 7 apps, including Bamboo, HiBob, and Expensify. |
Data security | Excellent | Excellent | Deel is GDPR and SOC 1,2 and 3 compliant and ISO 27001 certified. Papaya Global is compliant with GDPR and SOC 1 &2 standards, ISO 27001 and ISO 22201 certified, and CSA Star Level 1 attested. |
International hiring (EOR) | Excellent | Excellent | Deel provides support for hiring employees and contractors in 150+ countries. Oyster extends that reach to over 160 countries worldwide. |
Recruitment | Not offered | Not offered | Neither provider offers recruitment services |
Benefits administration | Very good | Good | Deel manages standard benefits like PTO, bonuses, and social security. Oyster offers health insurance packages in 160+ countries. |
Payroll | Very good | Excellent | Both providers offer comprehensive global payroll services. Deel offers clients more payment options than Papaya Global. |
Main Differences: Papaya Global vs Deel
In the competitive landscape of the global employer of record (EOR) industry, Papaya Global and Deel stand out as key players.
Both companies offer robust solutions designed to simplify the hiring process for businesses aiming to expand their global footprint. While their services may seem similar at first glance, a closer examination reveals distinct differences that can influence your decision on which platform to choose.
With their primary offerings centered around EOR support, contractor management, and global payroll, both companies enable businesses to legally hire employees in countries where they lack registered entities. By leveraging a network of subsidiaries and partners, these EOR providers handle employment contracts and manage various HR needs on behalf of their clients.
Papaya Global
Papaya Global has established itself as a prominent provider in the global payroll and EOR sector, focusing on streamlining the hiring process and ensuring compliance across various jurisdictions. With a strong emphasis on providing clients with a user-friendly platform, Papaya Global aims to alleviate the complexities of managing a global workforce.
Services offered by Papaya Global
- Employer of Record (EOR): Legal employment services in 160+ countries for seamless global hiring.
- Global Payroll: Comprehensive payroll management ensuring compliance with local tax laws.
- Contractor Management: Supports contractor hiring at $30 per contractor per month.
- Benefits Management: Enables clients to add health insurance and other benefits for employees.
- Mobile Accessibility: Offers the Papaya Personal app for employee self-service functions.
- API Integrations: Allows developers to create custom integrations, despite limited out-of-the-box solutions.
Deel
Deel has rapidly become a household name in the EOR industry, known for its commitment to helping companies hire talent globally without the need for local entities. Deel focuses on providing a robust platform that simplifies compliance and payroll management, making it a preferred choice for many international businesses.
Services offered by Deel
- Employer of Record (EOR): Comprehensive EOR services available in 150+ countries.
- Global Payroll: Simplifies payroll processing while ensuring compliance with local laws.
- Contractor Management: Offers contractor services for $49 per contractor per month.
- Software Integrations: Integrates with over 90 software solutions to enhance workflow efficiency.
- Mobile App: Provides a mobile app for on-the-go access to essential features.
- Compliance Management: Focuses on maintaining compliance with local labor laws.
Papaya Global Pricing
| Plan | Price per employee/contractor per month |
|---|---|
| Papaya Global EOR | Starting at $599 per full-time employee per month |
| Papaya Global Contractor | $30 per contractor per month |
| Papaya Global PayrollPlus | Starting at $15 – $25 per full-time employee per month |
| Papaya Global Payments | Starting at $2.5 per transactions |
| Papaya Global Agent of Record | Starting at $200 per contractor per month |
Deel Pricing
| Plan | Price per employee/contractor per month |
|---|---|
| Deel EOR Services | $499 per employee per month and up |
| Deel PEO Services | $79 per employee per month and up |
| Deel Contractor Management | $49 per contractor per month and up |
| Deel Payroll | $29 per person per month and up for global payroll or $19 per person per month and up for US payroll |
Key Differences
Service Expansion
- Papaya Global: Offers employee benefits management, which can enhance talent attraction and compliance.
- Deel: Does not include these additional offerings.
Global Reach
- Papaya Global: Operates in 160+ countries, providing a broader geographical service area.
- Deel: Covers 150+ countries, offering slightly less reach.
Pricing Transparency
- Papaya Global: Provides more competitive pricing for contractor management at $30 per contractor per month.
- Deel: Charges $49 per contractor per month, making it a less budget-friendly option for contractors.
While both Papaya Global and Deel provide valuable EOR services, your choice may ultimately hinge on specific business needs, such as contractor pricing, benefit offerings, and software integrations.
If you seek a more comprehensive solution that includes benefits and competitive contractor pricing, Papaya Global may be the better fit. However, if your focus is on extensive software integrations and a straightforward user experience, Deel could be the ideal partner for your global workforce management.
Papaya Global Pros and Cons
Papaya Global’s specific advantages and disadvantages include:
- Pros
Data security
Papaya Global is compliant with GDPR and SOC 1 &2 standards, ISO 27001 and ISO 22201 certified, and CSA Star Level 1 attested.
Benefits packages
This provider offers health insurance packages that can be added on for employees and managed within its platform. These packages can be tailored to employees’ needs or to the conditions mandated in the 160+ countries where they’re provided.
Contractor price
Payapa Global’s contractor management price of just $30/contractor per month is very affordable even for the smallest of small businesses.
- Cons
Limited integration
Papaya Global has an API that allows developers to build custom integrations with other software. However, its out-of-the-box integrations are limited. It only allows integration with seven other apps. While it offers “connectors” to help integrate with HCM, HRIS, and VMS software, greater integration with other software would make this platform much more convenient.
Invoicing issues
Papaya Global’s invoicing system has been criticized by users for lacking detail and for taking a long time to resolve invoicing disputes. This includes invoices for both clients and contractors.
Limited features
Unlike other providers in this space, Papaya Global lacks some important features that would otherwise allow it to act as a standalone human capital management (HCM) system. It doesn’t include recruitment management, applicant tracking, analytics, workflow, and reporting features.
Deel Pros and Cons
As a similar GEP service provider, Deel also has its specific pros and cons. These include.
- Pros
Free HR offering
Deel has a basic human resources information system (HRIS) called Deel HR. This system is “forever free” for small and medium enterprises (SMEs) with under 200 employees and can work as an easy way to pre-trial this system before signing up.
Efficient onboarding
Deel’s self-serve portal makes onboarding employees and contractors quick and easy. It automatically generates contracts, helps workers sign them online, and allows them to upload their necessary documents easily.
Data security
Deel complies with the SOC 1,2 and 3 and GDPR standards and is also ISO 27001 certified. It uses encryption protocols and 2FA (two-factor authentication) to further protect user data and privacy.
Easy payments
Deel pays employees around the world in 120 of their local currencies. It also allows contractors to pay in these currencies through direct deposits, online payment systems like Wise and Payoneer, or even cryptocurrencies. Deel can also bill clients in 24 global currencies.
- Cons
Lacks features
Much like Papaya Global, Deel lacks a lot of the features you’d need to use this platform as your only HCM system. Deel doesn’t include recruitment management, applicant tracking, analytics, workflow, or headcount features. In addition, Deel doesn’t yet offer a mobile app to allow employees and contractors to access the platform while on the go.
Complex pricing
Deel lists its prices online for contractor, EOR, and global payroll services. However, these are simply starting prices and may not reflect the actual cost in different countries. Adding services and features can also raise these prices, but it’s difficult to estimate costs without requesting a quote from Deel.
Contractor management price
At $49/person, Deel’s monthly contractor management price is a lot higher than many competitors in this space.
Platform complexity
While Deel’s platform has an intuitive user interface that’s easy for new users to interact with, it also includes very complex functionality. This can make it difficult to learn.
Head-to-Head Comparison: Papaya Global vs Deel Features
Now that we’ve had a chance to look at the pros and cons of each platform individually, it’s time to go head-to-head. Rather than taking Papaya vs Deel and trying to find an overall winner, our goal here is to compare these two service providers directly across several criteria to see where each one is a better choice.
User-friendly platform: It’s a tie
According to user reviews, Deel is slightly easier to use than Papaya Global. Deel has a fairly steep learning curve at first, which can be a challenge to overcome. However, once they get used to it, users find it convenient and intuitive. At the same time, users prefer Deel’s level of support, which they say is more attentive and helpful when issues occur. For these reasons, we’re calling it a draw between these two platforms.
Resources: It’s a tie
Deel’s resources include an ongoing blog, educational webinars, a global employment comparison tool, and a global benefits tool that helps calculate the costs of employees in different countries. Papaya Global features a blog, resource library, cost calculator, decision tree, and RFP template. These resources are quite evenly matched.
Integration with other software: Deel Wins
Deel can integrate with over 90 software solutions, including Ashby, Asana, BambooHR, Greenhouse, HiBob, Lever, Quickbooks, Slack, Workable, Workday, and Zapier. It includes an API developers can use to build new integrations. Papaya Global also has an API as well as “connectors” to help with data transfer from HR and financial software. However, it only offers seven out-of-the-box integrations (SAP, Oracle, Netsuite, Bamboo, Namely, HiBob, Expensify), which is much more limited.
International hiring (EOR): It’s a tie
Both Papaya Global and Deel provide EOR services, including hiring, onboarding and offboarding, payroll, taxes, and benefits administration. Deel works in 150+ countries and Papaya Global in 160+, but the difference is too slight to make much difference.
Contractor Solution: Papaya Global Wins
Deel excels at offering flexible payment possibilities for contractors, including a wide array of currencies, online payments, direct deposits, and even a Deel Card (debit card). At the same time, Deel’s contractor price is high at $49 per contractor per month. This is why Papaya Global takes this category with its much more affordable $30 per contractor per month.
Employee Benefits: Papaya Global Wins
Both service providers administer the mandatory benefits that must be provided for employees in different countries, including social security contributions and PTO. However, Deel doesn’t offer other benefits to international employees, just US workers. Papaya Global, on the other hand, lets employers add health care insurance packages for their employees and manages these conveniently within its platform.
Payroll Management: Deel Wins
Both Papaya Global and Deel simplify payroll management by automatically calculating salaries and deductions through their platforms and facilitating contractor invoices. Deel wins for payroll because it provides a range of payment options for compensation contractors and lets clients choose from 24 currencies to be billed in, while Papaya Global offers only 14.
Our Verdict: Papaya Global vs Deel
Now that we’ve seen these two service providers individually and compared them in specific categories, it’s time to make a choice. We don’t need to choose one or the other as the overall winner. Instead, we want to help you choose which of these platforms best suits your organization’s needs.
When to choose Papaya Global
Smaller organizations that want to hire contractors will be happy with Papaya Global’s options and low prices. This is also the provider to choose if you want or need to provide health insurance packages for your global employees.
When to choose Deel
Deel is a great choice for organizations that prioritize flexible payments to keep high-quality contractors happy. Deel also makes Payroll easy by providing many billing options. And if you want a platform that’s more likely to integrate seamlessly with your tech stacks, this is the right choice.
Hire Globally. Stay Compliant.
- Hire in 150+ countries
- EOR from $199/mo
- In-house recruiters
- Humans, not chatbots
Switching from another EOR? We handle the migration for free.